Articles
No. 7 (2025)
Worker Co-operatives and Industrial Democracy in Ireland: Historical Perspectives, Legal Frameworks, and Pathways for Growth
Abstract
Worker co-operatives, firms owned and democratically administered by their workers, provide a robust type of industrial democracy with significant historical foundations in Ireland and the European Union (EU). This article analyses the progression of worker co-operatives within these circumstances, mapping their emergence as reactions to social inequity, economic disruption, and the pursuit of fair working standards. It rigorously examines the legal frameworks governing worker co-operatives in Ireland and the EU, emphasising the obstacles presented by fragmented law, restricted access to financing, and insufficient support mechanisms.
Notwithstanding governmental support for co-operative principles at the EU level, worker co- operatives constitute a rather insignificant industry. This article examines obstacles to expansion, such as cultural prejudices against conventional corporate methods and insufficient understanding of co-operative governance. Utilising successful models from nations such as Spain and Italy, it delineates plans for development, including adjustments to Irish and EU law, augmented financial assistance, and education about the advantages of co-operative enterprises.
This article presents a historical and legal study that highlights the capacity of worker co-operatives to mitigate economic inequality and promote industrial democracy in Ireland and the EU. It desires focused governmental measures to fully realise the sector's groundbreaking potential.
References
- • ‘Administrative Law’ (2004) 18 Annual Review of Irish Law 1
View in Google Scholar
- • Barrett E, ‘Getting the Price Right - Could a Reintroduction of Temporary Price Controls Solve the Problem of Increasing Renewable Energy in Ireland While Simultaneously Guaranteeing Affordable Electricity to Domestic Consumers?’ (2014) 37 Dublin University Law Journal 21 accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Briscoe R and Ward M, ‘The Competitive Advantages of Co-Operatives’ (UCC Centre for Co-operative Studies 2000) <https://www.ucc.ie/en/media/research/centreforcooperativestudies/publications/ BriscoeWard,2000TheCompAdvBookwithoutcovers.pdf> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Call for New Share Scheme for Employees’ Law Society of Ireland Gazette (2021) accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Carey E, ‘Co-Operative Identity – Do You Need a Law about It?’ (2009) 42 Journal of Co-operative Studies 49 <https://hubble-live-assets.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/uk-society-for-co-operative-studies/ file_asset/file/545/s6Carey-125.pdf> accessed 24 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Carroll B, ‘Facing Crises: Challenges and Opportunities Confronting the Third Sector and Civil Society’, Ninth International Conference of the International Society for Third Sector Research (ISTR) (2010) <https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.istr.org/resource/resmgr/working_papers_istanbul/carroll_wp10.pdf> accessed 29 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Ireland’ in Dante Cracogna, Antonio Fici and Hagen Henry (eds), International Handbook of Co-operative Law (Springer 2013) <https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-642-30129-2_21> accessed 24 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Carroll B and Dunkin F, ‘Economic Democracy and Worker Co-Operatives: The Case for Ireland’ (Research Gate9 April 2019) <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/ 342212628_The_Society_for_Co- operative_Studies_in_Ireland_in_conjunction_with_SIPTU_presents_SEMINAR_PROCEEDINGS_Econ omic_democracy_and_worker_co-operatives_the_case_for_Ireland> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Chubb B, Dunne J and Hamilton T, ‘Industrial Democracy: Its Background and Implications’ (1969) 58 Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review 135 <https://www.jstor.org/stable/30088673> accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Conaty P, Bird A and Ross C, ‘Working Together: Trade Union and Co-Operative Innovations for Precarious Workers’ (Co-operatives UK 2018) <http://base.socioeco.org/docs/cuk_and_cc_- _working_together_final_print-quality.pdf>
View in Google Scholar
- • Crowley C and Power C, ‘Could Care Co-Operatives Be an Answer to Home Care Crisis?’ RTÉ Brainstorm (25 March 2024) <https://www.rte.ie/brainstorm/2024/0325/1439809-ireland-home-care-older- people-care-co-operatives/> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Curran I, ‘Ireland’s €9.7bn Co-Op Sector to Get Boost from “Long-Awaited” Legislation’ (The Irish Times2023) <https://www.irishtimes.com/business/2023/02/15/long-awaited-historic-bill-could- boost-97bn-co-op-sector/> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Dahl D, ‘For Some, Worker Cooperatives Emerge as an Alternative to ESOPs’ Forbes (14 August 2016) <https://www.forbes.com/sites/darrendahl/2016/08/14/for-some-worker-cooperatives-emerge-as-an- alternative-to-esops/> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Doyle G, ‘Socialising Economic Development in Ireland: Social Enterprise an Untapped Resource’ (TUD 2018) <https://arrow.tudublin.ie/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1021&context=beschspart> accessed 29 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘A New Epoch for Worker Co- Operatives in Ireland - An Outline of the Factors Required for Their Implementation and the Opportunities to Address Precarious Employment’ (Technological University Dublin 2022) <https://www.nerinstitute.net/sites/default/files/2022-06/ Gerard%20Doyle%20TU%20Dublin%20presentation%202B%2014%20June%2022.pdf> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Co-Op Care - the Case for Co-Operative Care in Ireland’ (Jesuit Centre for Faith & Justice 2022) accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Employee Share Schemes’ (Citizens’ Information Board2018) <https://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/ money-and-tax/tax/tax-on-savings-and-investments/employee-share-option-schemes/> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Empowering Care: Ireland’s First Care Workers’ Co-Op’ RTE.ie (14 March 2024) <https://www.rte.ie/ lifestyle/living/2024/0314/1437893-empowering-care-irelands-first-care-workers-co-op/> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘EUR-Lex - 52004DC0018 - EN’ (Europa.eu2024) <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/ HTML/?uri=CELEX:52004DC0018> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Fanning C, ‘Some Issues Concerning the Founding of Labour Directed Firms’ (ESRI 1983) accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Fanning CM, ‘Ireland: Industrial Co-Operatives’ [1982] The Performance of Labour-Managed Firms 141
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Finance Bill 2021: Committee and Remaining Stages’ (2021) 281 Oireachtas.ie
View in Google Scholar
- &highlight%5B7%5D=co&highlight%5B8%5D=operative> accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘First Specific Legislation on Co-Ops Proposed’ (Law Gazette2022) <https://www.lawsociety.ie/gazette/
View in Google Scholar
- top-stories/2022/november/first-specific-legislation-on-co-ops-proposed>
View in Google Scholar
- • Gavin M and others, ‘The Worker Co-Operative Sector in Ireland: Current Status, Future Prospects’ (2014)
View in Google Scholar
- 47 Journal of Co-operative Studies <https://hubble-live-assets.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/uk-society- for-co-operative-studies/file_asset/file/270/2014_JCS_47_2__GavinEtAl-141.pdf> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Good for Business? Worker Participation on Boards’ (TASC 2012) <https://issuu.com/tascpublications/ docs/worker_directors_final130712? mode=embed&layout=http%3A%2F%2Fskin.issuu.com%2Fv%2Flight%2Flayout.xml&showFlipBtn=tru e&proShowMenu=true&proShowSidebar=true> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Guide to Profit Sharing Schemes’ (Revenue.ie) <https://www.taxfind.ie/binaryDocument//pdfs/ http___www_revenue_ie_en_tax_it_leaflets_it62_pdf_20160421233015.pdf> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Hall E, ‘Communications’ (1996) 10 Annual Review of Irish Law 77
View in Google Scholar
- • Harvey R, ‘Co-Ops vs Competition Law’ (Co-operative News2 July 2021) <https://www.thenews.coop/co-
View in Google Scholar
- ops-vs-competition-law/> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Hosford D, ‘Reforming the Irish Economy – the Co-Operative Way’ (Magill2012) <https://magill.ie/
View in Google Scholar
- society/reforming-irish-economy-%E2%80%93-co-operative-way> accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Industrial Relations’ (Workplace Relations Commission2012) <https://www.workplacerelations.ie/en/
View in Google Scholar
- what_you_should_know/industrial_relations/> accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Ireland’s Co-Operative Sector’ (Forfás 2007) <https://www.serni.ie/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Ireland-
View in Google Scholar
- s-Co-operative-Sector.pdf> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Joint Committee on Business, Enterprise and Innovation Debate - Tuesday, 25 Jun
View in Google Scholar
- 2019’ (Oireachtas.ie2019) <https://www.oireachtas.ie/en/debates/debate/ joint_committee_on_business_enterprise_and_innovation/2019-06-25/3/? highlight%5B0%5D=worker&highlight%5B1%5D=co&highlight%5B2%5D=operatives&highlight%5B3 %5D=law&highlight%5B4%5D=worker&highlight%5B5%5D=co&highlight%5B6%5D=operatives> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Joint Committee on Enterprise, Trade and Employment: Report on the Pre-Legislative Scrutiny of the General Scheme of the Co-Operative Societies Bill, 2022’ (Houses of the Oireachtas 2023) accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Jones C and Murphy P, ‘Worker Participation - Ireland’ (Europa.eu18 July 2013) accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Key Employee Engagement Programme’, Tax & Duty Manual (Revenue 2021) <https://www.revenue.ie/ en/tax-professionals/tdm/share-schemes/Chapter-09-20211231151829.pdf> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Key Employee Engagement Programme “Gets It 85% Correct”’ RTÉ News (20 October 2017) accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Kinsella P, Bourke B and Morrissey E, ‘General Scheme of the Co-Operative Societies Bill 2022’ (Vlex.com2023) <https://justis.vlex.com/vid/921633354> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Laliberté P, ‘Trade Unions and Worker Cooperatives: Where Are We At?’ (2013) 5 International Journal of Labour Research <https://base.socioeco.org/docs/wcms_240534.pdf#page=57> accessed 29 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Lockey A and Glover B, ‘The Wealth Within: The “Preston Model” and the New Municipalism’ (Demos 2019) <https://www.sheffieldtribune.co.uk/content/files/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/june-final-web.pdf> accessed 29 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Maher I, ‘The Implementation of EC Competition Law in Ireland: The Transition to a New Statutory Regime’ (1993) 28/30 Irish Jurist 21 <https://www.jstor.org/stable/44026382> accessed 29 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • McMahon C, ‘Co-Operatives and the Future of Work in Ireland’ (2019) <https://www.tasc.ie/assets/files/
View in Google Scholar
- pdf/ensuring_good_future_jobs.pdf#page=45> accessed 29 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Nolan S, Massebiaux EP and Gorman T, ‘Saving Jobs, Promoting Democracy: Worker Co-
View in Google Scholar
- Operatives’ (2013) 21 Irish Journal of Sociology 103
View in Google Scholar
- • O’Connor R and Kelly P, ‘A Study of Industrial Workers’ Co-Operatives’ (ESRI 1980)
View in Google Scholar
- www.esri.ie/system/files/media/file-uploads/2012-08/BS19.pdf> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • O’Donovan B, ‘Ireland Expects to Meet EU Deadline on Workers’ Rights’ RTÉ News (15 November 2024) <https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2024/1115/1481006-workers-rights-directive/> accessed 23 December
View in Google Scholar
- 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Prospects for Workers’ Co-Operatives in Europe’ (Commission of the European Communities 1984)
View in Google Scholar
- <http://aei.pitt.edu/33684/1/A218.pdf> accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Reform and Modernisation of Legislation Regarding Co-Operative Societies: Policy Response to Issues
View in Google Scholar
- Raised in Public Consultation’ (Department of Enterprise, Trade & Employment 2022) accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Rooney PM, ‘ESOPS, Producer Coops, and Traditional Firms: Are They Different?’ (1992) 26 Journal of Economic Issues 593 <https://www.jstor.org/stable/4226572> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Share Based Remuneration’ (Commission on Taxation and Welfare 2022) <https://assets.gov.ie/ 234151/44fbc527-c416-45de-9fb9-63fee6ca07ef.pdf> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Sharma A and Gupta N, ‘The Crippling State of Collective Bargaining in Ireland’ (Kcl.ac.uk21 June 2021) <https://blogs.kcl.ac.uk/kslreuropeanlawblog/?p=1609> accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Sixth Report of the Joint Committee on Small Business - the Development and Management of Small Business Co-Operatives: Motion’ (1987) 117 Oireachtas Debates <https://www.oireachtas.ie/en/debates/ debate/seanad/1987-11-18/6/? highlight%5B0%5D=co&highlight%5B1%5D=operatives&highlight%5B2%5D=worker&highlight%5B3 %5D=co&highlight%5B4%5D=operatives&highlight%5B5%5D=worker&highlight%5B6%5D=co&highl ight%5B7%5D=operatives&highlight%5B8%5D=workers&highlight%5B9%5D=co&highlight%5B10%5 D=operative&highlight%5B11%5D=co&highlight%5B12%5D=operative> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Taft M, ‘Stumbling at the Threshold: Democracy in the Irish Economy’ (2024) 113 Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review 488 <https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/420/article/948129> accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Teague P, ‘Social Partnership and the Enterprise Some Lessons from the Irish Experience’ (2004) 2 European Political Economy Review 6 <http://aei.pitt.edu/6047/1/teague.pdf> accessed 23 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Toomer-McAlpine A, ‘Irish Co-Op Brings Home a New Model of Social Care’ (Co-operative News25 July
View in Google Scholar
- 2024) <https://www.thenews.coop/irish-co-op-brings-home-a-new-model-of-social-care/> accessed 22
View in Google Scholar
- December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Vieta M, ‘The Italian Road to Creating Worker Cooperatives from Worker Buyouts: Italy’s Worker-
View in Google Scholar
- Recuperated Enterprises and the Legge Marcora Framework’ (Euricsa 2015) <https://base.socioeco.org/
View in Google Scholar
- docs/wp-78_15_vieta.pdf> accessed 29 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Voinea A, ‘Irish Co-Ops Share Views on Co-Operative Societies Bill’ (Co-operative News3 March 2023)
View in Google Scholar
- <https://www.thenews.coop/irish-co-op-apex-raises-concerns-with-ministers-over-co-operative-societies-
View in Google Scholar
- bill/> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘What Is a SAYE Scheme? Here Is All You Need to Know.’ (Hyland Johnson Keane3 May 2023)
View in Google Scholar
- hjk.ie/saye-scheme/> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Worker Co-Operatives and Right to Buy Bill 2021’ (Oireachtas.ie19 May 2021)
View in Google Scholar
- www.oireachtas.ie/en/bills/bill/2021/94/?tab=bill-text> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • ‘Worker Participation on Boards’ (Rosalux.de3 May 2013) <https://www.rosalux.de/en/news/id/6749/
View in Google Scholar
- worker-participation-on-boards> accessed 22 December 2024
View in Google Scholar
- • Kerry Co-Operative Creameries Ltd v an Bord Bainne [1991] ILRM 851
View in Google Scholar
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.